TBA
Apollonia's Pizzeria
I'm not sure how Apollonia's Pizzeria has such a massive crowd this many years in, but kudos to them for keeping things up. Their Sicilian pizza slices have a wonderful thick crust, and their Acapulco gold piza is very, very cheesy. The pepperoni doesn't overwhelm like some of their competitors, which is good or bad depending on where you stand. It's a good balance, although I honestly also don't mind overkill there.
Show up 10 minutes before opening if you can, any later and you risk a serious wait. Heck, even showing up that early and being their second or third order, I still had a 15 minute wait for my two slices.